Would you trust me to sit in judgment of you?
I ask because I’m a woman and there’s an opening on the all-male Indiana Supreme Court.
The answer to my question, of course, is no. I may have good judgment about some things, but with no law degree or legal experience of any kind, I’m not even close to being qualified.
But on the list of 22 applicants who have applied for the job, there are 16 smart women who are. There are some smart men on the list, too, but I’m not here to make their case.
In the past 30 years, there’s been a remarkable change in what it looks like to be a lawyer. According to the National Women’s Law Center, the number of female law students was close to 45 percent for 25 of those 30 years. The gender breakdown now is about half and half.
So law schools and law firms are filled with women, but that’s not so on the bench. The judiciary is still dominated by men, handing down judgments in criminal and civil cases and deciding what’s law.
Here’s why the National Women’s Law Center says that’s so wrong: When women are fairly represented in the judiciary, our courts more fairly reflect the diversity of the nation. And when women are fairly represented on the bench, women and men will likely have more confidence that the court understands the real-world implications of its rulings.
Here’s more: The increased presence of women on the bench improves the quality of justice because those women can bring an understanding of the impact of laws on the lives of women in ways that men can’t. They enrich their colleagues’ understanding of how best to realize the intended aims and impact of the law that the courts are charged with applying.
When the state’s Judicial Nominating Commission begins its first round of interviews of Supreme Court candidates on July 16-17, no doubt that case will be made by some applicants and commission members alike.
It’s already been made a couple of times. Gov. Mitch Daniels has appointed two justices to the state Supreme Court during his tenure — both smart, well-qualified men who were vetted by the nominating commission and among the top finalists recommended to Daniels.
Here’s the closing argument I’d make, borrowed from U.S. Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsberg in an early 2009 interview with The New York Times, when — after the retirement of Justice Sandra Day O’Connor — she was the only woman on the nation’s top court: It just doesn’t look right.
Here’s her full quote (taken from the Times story, which also described what Justice Ginsberg was wearing during the interview, right down to her earrings): “My basic concern about being all alone was the public got the wrong perception of the court. It just doesn’t look right in the year 2009.”
So it’s 2012 already. Time for the Indiana Supreme Court to start to look less male and a more right.
Maureen Hayden covers the Statehouse for the CNHI newspapers in Indiana. She can be reached at email@example.com.
Would you trust me to sit in judgment of you?
Changed wording delays debate on right to hunt, fish
INDIANAPOLIS -- A much-debated ban on same-sex marriage wasn't the only proposed constitutional amendment to get knocked off this November's ballot. Gone, too, is the less contentious proposal to protect Hoosiers' right to hunt and fish. Backers of t
Couples want equal rights in same-sex suit
LOUISVILLE -- Erin Brock says she's prepared to fight to have her love legally recognized by the state of Indiana. Brock and her financé Melissa Love share a home and children in Jeffersonville and are one of four same-sex couples from Southern India
Business tax cuts enter House, Senate negotiations
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — A package of business tax cuts is on its way to negotiations between Indiana House and state Senate lawmakers following a party-line vote in the Senate. The Senate voted 33-15 Tuesday to advance the package, sending it to a confer
Indianapolis mass transit bill clears both Houses
Eds: Updates with additional details, quotes. Changes headline. INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Funding for an expanded bus system serving the greater Indianapolis area has cleared both chambers of the Indiana General Assembly, also opening the door to the poss
Officials seek $3.4M seized from Ind. restaurants
LAFAYETTE (AP) — Prosecutors have filed lawsuits seeking to keep more than $3.4 million seized during police raids last fall at about two dozen Mexican restaurants across Indiana. Civil forfeiture lawsuits have been filed in Tippecanoe and Marion cou
Bill advances to legalize pot's less potent cousin: hemp
INDIANAPOLIS -- Gregg Baumbaugh has 4,000 pounds of cannabis sitting in his automobile parts manufacturing plant. It wasn't illegal for him to import it, but it's against the law for Indiana farmers to grow the variety of cannabis he buys in bulk. B
New I-65 interchange in Greenwood delayed a year
GREENWOOD (AP) — Officials say construction of a new Interstate 65 interchange in a southern Indianapolis suburb is being delayed for a year. The state highway department says it hasn't been able to reach land purchase agreements with five property o
Indiana bills seek to shelter digital privacy
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Indiana lawmakers fed up with the National Security Agency scandal and other government snooping are pushing bills that would ban high-tech searches of cellphones, computer tablets and other digital devices without a warrant. Two
Explosion destroys small building in W. Ind. city
ATTICA, Ind. (AP) — An explosion has destroyed a small building in the western Indiana city of Attica. Mayor Robert Shepherd tells WLFI-TV that he's been told one person might have been inside the building at the time, but that injuries weren't immed
Heavy snow closes schools, city offices
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Travel has been snarled across Indiana as crews clean up from heavy snowfall or freezing rain in much of the state. Most counties across Indiana are asking people to restrict their travel and many schools, universities and government offices have closed for the day or delayed their Wednesday openings.
- Changed wording delays debate on right to hunt, fish